Business hopes for the British government are at rock bottom

The UK’s main growth industry at the moment appears to be government advisory and reviews yielding disappointing results.

The British economy may have contracted in April, with output falling across services, manufacturing and construction. But the business of preparing lengthy advisory papers or commissioning heavy independent reports before results are largely ignored has rarely been more thriving.

This, in turn, supports a thriving network of pressure groups and internal departments, as they read, absorb and respond to the latest ambitious reforms that will often come true, while wondering what it might mean for a company if the government will actually see the rhetoric this time around.

It probably won’t. Only half of the recommendations will be adopted from a landmark review of the diet in England after the “narrative” was changed from Downing Street. It took four years, three reports and one consultation to loosen and delay auditing and corporate governance reform. An energy strategy that bore so much promise was trivial on delivery. AWOL is the most powerful and much discussed internet regulator, along with the tougher consumer protection and competition framework it’s a part of.

The 2017 Industrial Strategy, which was incomplete but worth the business, was re-launched as a blueprint for growth, discarded and can now be re-launched again. A seven-year promise to “radical” business rate reform ended with minor changes, ignoring calls for fundamental reforms and launching the idea of ​​a tax on online sales at another consultation, yes.

The various post-Brexit reviews on financial services are – really – too many to mention and they seem to be yielding at least some results. Everything that might happen against the backdrop of Matthew Taylor’s independent review of the UK job market and modern hiring practices remains a mystery five years later. I can go on.

Of course, every mitigating and reform proposal on the shelves has winners and losers: perhaps the food and beverage sector encourages payments of salt and sugar taxes. But, in general, the endless cycle of consulting and reviewing, from launch and relaunch, reflects a lack of coherence and conviction around economic and business thinking.

“There is a failure to develop consistent strategies or confidence that they will be pursued,” says Giles Wilkes of the Institute of Government, who researches the issue. “This hurts business incentives to invest at the microeconomic level, even as the macroeconomic picture deteriorates.”

The CBI is starting to look desperate. Tony Danker, managing director of the business group, issued a plea to focus on the economy, rather than throwing political red meat on parts of the board of governors. This includes rolling back the standoff over the Northern Ireland Protocol.

However, much of CIB’s emergency to-do list to maintain business investment, which it says is keeping the UK out of recession, is pretty modest. Rather than urging a change of course, it largely amounts to an appeal to the government to do things it has already indicated it will do: cutting the approval time for wind farms from four years to one was in the energy strategy; The advisor’s successor to the super-discount on business investment was promised this fall; Reportedly, the replacement of the Covid-19 recovery loan scheme is in full swing.

It’s not all that simple: A call to “take a real stand” on the labor shortage may include rolling back ill-advised comments made last October that it was all part of the high-wage, skilled economy’s plan (middle seemingly limiting) to be the tightest of pressure on living standards since the 1950s).

But the CBI is essentially asking the government to implement its own policies – perhaps even in the quick and clever way we’ve been told is a win-win for a post-Brexit government. This is intentional: Behind the scenes, I’m told, the business community has been talking to departments about dozens of other changes that appear to have government support but seem stuck in a policy stalemate.

The question is how to break this political or logistical impasse. I can feel another review coming.

[email protected]
Tweet embed

Leave a Comment